This article explains how to tell whether HMRC sees you as a hobby seller or a trader.

Who Is This For?

Best for: UK private sellers, casual Vinted/eBay users, parents selling kids’ clothes, and new resellers unsure about tax rules.

Selling second-hand clothes online has become a popular side hustle in the UK, especially with platforms like Vinted, Depop, and eBay making it easy to list items. But with HMRC now receiving data from these platforms from 2025, many sellers worry: “Do I need to pay tax?”

The good news is that not everyone who sells old clothes is liable. The key is understanding the difference between casual selling and trading for profit. This article will walk you through the rules, common mistakes, checklists, and practical tips to stay compliant - plus, we’ll show you how Zipsale can make managing sales and records effortless.

Private Seller vs Trader

Understanding whether HMRC sees you as a private seller or a trader is crucial. The distinction affects whether your earnings are taxable.

Comparison Table: Private Seller vs Trader

Example:
If you bought a coat three years ago for £80 and sell it for £35, it’s a loss, not taxable income. But if you buy 10 vintage jackets for £20 each and sell them for £50 each, HMRC could consider this a trading activity.

Common Misconceptions (Red Flags)

Many casual sellers make assumptions that lead to unnecessary panic. Avoid these mistakes:

Misconception 1: “Selling my kids’ old clothes is taxable.”

Reality: Personal items sold at a loss are not taxable. Even if the total sale is £500, HMRC generally does not consider it trade.

Misconception 2: “If HMRC receives platform data, I will automatically owe tax.”

Reality: Platforms report your sales, but HMRC only taxes profits from trade, not casual sales.

Misconception 3: “Selling over 30 items makes me a trader.”

Reality: There is no fixed item threshold. HMRC looks at intent, profit motive, and business-like behavior, not raw numbers.

Misconception 4: “Income under £1,000 is irrelevant.”

Reality: The £1,000 Trading Allowance means you do not owe tax if gross income is below this level. Keep in mind it’s income, not profit, that counts.

‍

Checklist - Do You Need to File a Self-Assessment?

Here’s a step-by-step guide to know if you must file:

You do NOT need to file if:

• You sell personal items at a loss
• Your selling is occasional, like seasonal wardrobe clear-outs
• Your total income from all platforms is under £1,000/year

You DO need to file if:

• You buy items specifically to resell for profit
• You sell regularly or systematically
• You exceed the £1,000 Trading Allowance
• You hold inventory or stock, e.g., from wholesalers

Pro Tip: Even if your gross sales are above £1,000 but profit is minimal or negative, you should still register for Self-Assessment to clarify your position with HMRC.

Let's see Practical Examples!

Scenario A: Casual Seller

• Sarah sells 50 of her children’s outgrown clothes on Vinted.
• Total sales: £2,500
• Cost originally paid: £3,000
• Tax outcome: £0 - she is selling personal items at a loss.

Scenario B: Weekend Reseller

• Mike buys vintage jackets at car boot sales for £20 each, sells them online for £50 each.
• Total sales: £3,500
• Expenses: £1,500
• Profit: £2,000
• Tax outcome: Taxable. Mike is considered a trader and must file Self-Assessment.

These examples illustrate that volume alone doesn’t determine tax liability - it’s about intent and profit.

How to Avoid Pitfalls

Red Flags to Watch For

• Ignoring HMRC letters (they have the data)
• Mixing personal and business finances
• Thinking cash sales are untaxed if trading
• Forgetting to aggregate sales across multiple platforms

Tip: Track your sales and expenses accurately across all marketplaces to avoid errors or overpayment.

How Zipsale Helps

Managing multiple platforms can be chaotic, especially when trying to determine whether you are trading or not. Zipsale provides:

• Centralised dashboard: View your total sales volume across Vinted, eBay, Depop, and more
• Inventory tracking: Keep records of each item sold, when, and at what price
• Profit clarity: Calculate profit/loss for each sale to prove whether you are trading or just decluttering
• Cross-listing automation: List your items on multiple platforms in minutes without confusion

By consolidating your sales, Zipsale ensures you have accurate records to submit for Self-Assessment if needed, or to prove your sales are casual and tax-free. It also saves hours of manual entry, letting you focus on selling more items efficiently.

Glossary

• Trading Allowance - £1,000 tax-free allowance for casual income.
• Capital Gains Tax - Tax on profit from selling assets (not relevant to most used clothes).
• UTR Number - Unique Taxpayer Reference required for Self-Assessment.
• Self-Assessment - HMRC form for reporting taxable income.
• Side Hustle Tax - Media term for new HMRC rules starting in 2025.
• Marketplace Reporting - Platforms reporting seller data to HMRC.
• Cross-Listing - Listing the same item on multiple marketplaces simultaneously.